March 31, 2023
Wang Ping
Wang Ping, left, a professor of English at Macalester College in St. Paul, Minn., presents gifts of Eastern red cedar, known as the tree of life in Native American communities, and sacred water from Coldwater Spring to a member of the Eagle Butte, S.D. tribe on Saturday while both were at a makeshift camp near Standing Rock, N.D., where protesters are working to block the Dakota Access Pipeline from going under the Missouri River just north of the the Indian reservation. (Submitted photo)

STANDING ROCK (Dec. 4, 2016) — The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers on Sunday announced that it would not be granting an easement under Lake Oahe for the Dakota Access pipeline to cross the Missouri River a half mile upstream of the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe reservation.

In a press release, the environmental nonprofit Earthjustice said the Corps said it plans to prepare an Environmental Impact StatementEnvironmental Impact Statement for alternative routes. These actions trigger a new round of public involvement processes to permit the final piece of the pipeline as required by the National Environmental Policy Act. The decision is major victory for the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe and all who stood in solidarity over the last few months.

The Standing Rock Sioux Tribe, represented by Earthjustice, brought a lawsuit against the Corps for its approvals for the pipeline in July of this year. The lawsuit claimed that the Corps violated multiple environmental and historic preservation statutes, focusing on the decision to reroute the pipeline from Bismarck, North Dakota to the doorstep of the Standing Rock reservation without and adequate environmental analysis and consultation.  At various times, pipeline construction has been subject to court injunctions due to the litigation.

The Corps granted permits for the pipeline in July 2016 under a highly streamlined approval process known as Nationwide Permitting. The process circumvents any kind of close environmental review and public process. The Lake Oahe crossing requires an additional approval — known as an easement — because it crosses federally owned land on either side of the Missouri River. It was this easement that the government confirmed would not be granted.

Standing Rock Sioux Tribe Chairman Dave Archambault II said the tribes “wholeheartedly support the decision of the administration and commend with the utmost gratitude the courage it took on the part of President Obama, the Army Corps, the Department of Justice and the Department of the Interior to take steps to correct the course of history and to do the right thing.”

“We want to thank everyone who played a role in advocating for this cause,” Archambalt said. “We thank the tribal youth who initiated this movement. We thank the millions of people around the globe who expressed support for our cause. We thank the thousands of people who came to the camps to support us, and the tens of thousands who donated time, talent, and money to our efforts to stand against this pipeline in the name of protecting our water. We especially thank all of the other tribal nations and jurisdictions who stood in solidarity with us, and we stand ready to stand with you if and when your people are in need.

“With this decision we look forward to being able to return home and spend the winter with our families and loved ones, many of whom have sacrificed as well. We look forward to celebrating in wopila, in thanks, in the coming days.”

Jan Hasselman, the Earthjustice attorney who represented the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe in their lawsuit to deny this permit, said it is an historic day both for the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe and for indigenous people everywhere.

“This pipeline never should have been routed near these sacred lands in the first place, and it absolutely never should have received permits without a thorough and meaningful discussion of the risks and benefits to affected Indian Tribes,” Hasselman said. “Today’s announcement that a full environmental impact statement will be prepared is a huge step towards rational decision-making for a project of this magnitude.”

“Dakota Access took a reckless gamble with its investor’s money when it built its pipeline to either side of the river without the easement,” he said. “Despite the extraordinary public controversy and overwhelming opposition to this pipeline, Dakota Access rejected the government’s request to voluntary cease construction. Today, Dakota Access and its investors reap the consequences of this reckless gamble.”

U.S. Rep. Betty McCollum (DFL-Minn.), co-chair of the Congressional Native American Caucus, said the full environmental impact statement will appropriately consider the significant environmental and cultural concerns raised by the Standing Rock Sioux. She said the decision also underscores that it is in the best interest of all parties to explore new routes that safeguard the environment and protect tribal sovereignty.

“As the review takes place, I urge the United States Department of Justice to continue to work with the Army Corps of Engineers and the State of North Dakota to ensure that well-being, safety, and constitutional rights of protesters at Standing Rock are protected,” McCollum said.

“President Obama’s respect for the sovereignty and traditions of the Standing Rock Sioux and all tribal nations has been a hallmark of his administration, she said. “I applaud the ongoing efforts of the Department of the Interior and the Department of Justice to fully consult with tribal leaders in North Dakota and across Indian Country.”

In September, McCollum led 18 Democratic Members of Congress urging the Obama administration to undertake greater consultation with the Standing Rock Sioux on the Dakota Access Pipeline. Last week, McCollum joined Congressman Ron Kind (D-Wisc.) urging Attorney General Loretta Lynch to prioritize the health, safety, and constitutional rights of the protestors at Standing Rock.


North Dakota leaders, both democrat and republican, disagreed with the decision.

U.S. Sen. John Hoeven (R-ND) said the refusal to issue an easement for the Dakota Access Pipeline violates the rule of law and fails to resolve the issue. Instead, he said, it passes the decision off to the next administration, which has already indicated it will approve the easement, and in the meantime perpetuates a difficult situation for North Dakotans.

“Protesters should move from their unlawful site now that the Obama administration has made its decision,” Hoeven said. “By staying on the site, the protesters subject residents in the area to additional weeks of disruption and hardship.”

North Dakota Gov. Jack Dalrymple said decision to further postpone any action on the easement for the Dakota Access Pipeline is a serious mistake. He said it does nothing to resolve the issue, and only prolongs a serious problems faced by North Dakota law enforcement as they try to maintain public safety.

“The federal courts have already determined that the project developer has met or exceeded all U.S. Army Corps of Engineers’ requirements to build the pipeline,” Dalrymple said.

U.S. Sen. Heidi Heitkamp (D-ND) said the time for a decision is made on the easement going under Lake Oahe has passed. “The delay in taking action doesn’t bring finality to the project and keeps the pipeline status in limbo, she said.

“The incoming administration already stated its support for the project and the courts have already stated twice that it appeared the Corps followed the required process in considering the permit,” Heitkamp said. “For the next month and a half, nothing about this project will change. For the immediate future, the safety of residents, protesters, law enforcement, and workers remains my top priority as it should for everyone involved.”

U.S. Rep. Kevin Cramer (R-ND) called the decision, “lawless” and is essentially sending the decision to the next administration.

“In my conversation with Assistant Secretary of the Army Jo-Ellen Darcy today, she was unable to give any legal reasons for the decision and could not answer any questions about rerouting the pipeline,” Cramer said.


1 thought on “Victory for Standing Rock: DAPL easement not granted

  1. Sad to say it is just a temporary victory. With the coming of the Trump Presidency, the pipeline construction will resume, with no regards for Native rights and environment. What do you expect? Trump has named oil executives in key cabinet posts. So what do you think they will do? It’s sad because I visited the camp and was so impressed by the natives’ passion and organization. The tribes have people like Sanders, Steins and Johnson and their blind Third Party followers to blame for their impending doom. Their selfish and narrow-minded effort to demonize Hillary Clinton succeeded and effectively helped Trump win the White House. Had they stood united behind Hillary, we would have defeated Trump and buried the Republican Party. Instead, liberalism and politics of compassion is pushed back for generations and conservatism and Republican White privilege politics will rule for years. What did these Third Party lovers accomplished. Nothing because the prospect of having a Third Party is as likely as the Twins winning the World Series in the next 10 years. These morons did accomplish one thing–they put a liar, bigot and sexist in the White House. And those wonderful natives at Standing Rock will feel the wrath of the Trump Administration. Thanks a lot you Third Party dreamers.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *